• SA Cricketmag
    X
    • Home
    • Proteas
      • Proteas Men
      • Proteas Women
      • SA U19
    • SA20
    • Fixtures & Results
    • Videos
    • Opinion
    • Features
      • Magazine
      • Play of the Day
      • Top 5
      • Turbo Bowler
      • More
        • Schools
          • Fixtures
          • Results
        • IPL
          • IPL Fixtures & Results
          • Log
    • Soccermag

    SA Cricketmag

    Covering South African cricket, including the Proteas

    Primary Menu Search
    SA Cricketmag
    • Home
    • Proteas
      • Proteas Men
      • Proteas Women
      • SA U19
    • SA20
    • Fixtures & Results
    • Videos
    • Opinion
    • Features
      • Magazine
      • Play of the Day
      • Top 5
      • Turbo Bowler
      • More
        • Schools
          • Fixtures
          • Results
        • IPL
          • IPL Fixtures & Results
          • Log
    • Soccermag

    McCullum has gone rogue on Tests

    IPL IPL
    Published on May 15, 2018 | Leave a response

    I was surprised to see Brendon McCullum jumping on the bandwagon to proclaim that T20 will be the only form of cricket in the future.

    In an interview with Cricket Monthly, the former captain of New Zealand, who has 101 Tests to his name, said: ‘I firmly believe that Test cricket won’t be around in time, because there’s only so many teams that can afford to play it.’

    McCullum retired from international cricket in 2016 and now, like a hired gunslinger, plays in the IPL, the BBL, the CPL, the PSL and the BPL.

    He added that, long-term, he foresees T20 franchises as owning players… ‘and I don’t see them releasing those players to play for their nation in a Test match’.

    What an utterly bleak prospect that is. It’s a bit like saying that after a nuclear war, the only living creatures will be cockroaches.

    This is not a new idea… except that it has previously been limited to the IPL.

    IPL founder Lalit Modi believes that if restrictions were relaxed, players could soon be earning $1-million a game. The best players in the world, he says, will dedicate themselves solely to (IPL) T20.

    He even suggested that India didn’t need anyone else; the economy there would be big enough to sustain the IPL as the only tournament worth watching. He compared it to the money washing though European football, perhaps forgetting that their season lasts 10 months, not six weeks.

    The problem, I believe, is that players would have to reinvent themselves. The value of AB de Villiers, Virat Kohli, Chris Gayle and McCullum, to name just a few, lay in their displays in Test cricket.

    I also can’t quite work out the logistics of McCullum’s idea. If the franchises owned the players, they would have to find something for the players to do outside the six weeks of the IPL. Certainly, they could try to own all the T20 leagues across the world and take their players through England, Australia, the Caribbean, Pakistan (errr, skip that one), Bangladesh, and, maybe, South Africa.

    The problem with that is the governing bodies wouldn’t allow it. They know that T20 is the cash cow, but the very raison d’etre of cricket lies in Test cricket, and T20 will fund it.

    Can you imagine a cricket world without AB and Kohli in whites, playing their supreme shots against the best bowling attacks in the world? That is what defines them.

    Otherwise, it will come down to a lot of opportunists with very short lifespans. T2o needs Test cricket as much as Test cricket needs T20.

    Posted in Mark Salter Tagged ipl, T20, Test cricket

    Post by Mark Salter

    Mark Salter

    Follow @https://twitter.com/ScouterEcho on Twitter.

    ← Previous Next →
    Proteas arrive in Kolkata

    Watch: Proteas arrive in Kolkata

    The Proteas received a warm welcome in Kolkata ahead of their T20 World Cup semi-final against New Zealand.

    Stuart MacGill podcast

    Watch: Ex-Aussie spinner loses it on podcast

    Stuart MacGill threatened to punch his podcast co-host after he brought up South African fans wearing Sonny Bill Williams masks to taunt David Warner.

    • Home
    • Contact
    • Terms & conditions
    • News
    • Tournaments
    • Stats
    • Video

       

       

    Opinion

  • Gary Lemke
  • Mark Salter
  • Jon Cardinelli
  • CAPE TOWN OFFICE: 36 Old Mill Road, Ndabeni, Maitland, 7405, Western Cape > Telephone: (021) 530 3300 > Fax: (021) 530 3333
    ©Copyright 2026 SA Cricketmag

    Primary Menu

    • Home
    • Proteas
      • Proteas Men
      • Proteas Women
      • SA U19
    • SA20
    • Fixtures & Results
    • Videos
    • Opinion
    • Features
      • Magazine
      • Play of the Day
      • Top 5
      • Turbo Bowler
      • More
        • Schools
          • Fixtures
          • Results
        • IPL
          • IPL Fixtures & Results
          • Log
    • Soccermag